Validity of the Apple Watch® for monitoring push counts in people using manual wheelchairs
Published 27th February 2019
Karinharju, K., Boughey, A., Tweedy, S., Clanchy, K., Trost, S. & Gomersall, S.
Objective: A recent Apple Watch® activity-monitoring innovation permits manual wheelchair users to monitor daily push counts. This study evaluated the validity of the Apple Watch® push count estimate.
Design: Criterion validity.
Setting: Southern Finland and Southeast Queensland, Australia.
Participants: Twenty-six manual wheelchair users from Finland and Australia were filmed completing a standardized battery of activities while wearing the Apple Watch® (dominant wrist).
Outcome Measures: Wheelchair pushes as determined by the Apple Watch® were compared to directly observed pushes.
Results: Agreement between Apple Watch® push counts and directly observed pushes was evaluated using Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), Pearson correlations and Bland-Altman analyses. Apple Watch®pushes and directly observed push counts were strongly correlated (ICC = 0.77, P < 0.01) (r = 0.84, P < 0.01). Bland Altman plots indicated that the Apple Watch® underestimated push counts (M = −103; 95% ULoA = 217; LLoA = −423 pushes). Mean absolute percentage error was 13.5% which is comparable to studies evaluating agreement between pedometer-based step counts and directly observed steps.
Conclusion: Apple Watch® push-count estimates are acceptable for personal, self-monitoring purposes and for research entailing group-level analyses, but less acceptable where accurate push-count measures for an individual is required.
